• Search

We knew he would kill again

Reporter: Robbie Gill
Date online: 12 August 2014

THE parents of Janine Waterworth, who was murdered in High Crompton in 1998, have called for stricter sentences after her killer took the life of another woman in Rawtenstall in March.

Ian and Vera Waterworth, of Rishworth Rise, wrote to the parole board at the time of Paul O’Hara’s release to say he was dangerous.

Janine was murdered by O’Hara (43) in an alleyway 400 yards from her parents home as she walked to a bus stop on her way to work at 6.30am.

O’Hara had only been out on life licence for 23 months after serving 14 years before he killed Cherylee Shennan with a hammer, after trying to strangle her and stabbing her with a kitchen knife after she tried to run to safety.

Mr Waterworth (67) said he was not surprised that he killed again after he approached the authorities to express fears over O’Hara’s release.

He said: “I’d heard that a woman had been stabbed to death. I thought immediately that he’s done it again, we expected it. Probation said ‘you were right’, I didn’t want to be, it’s unbelievable.

“We had expressed concern about him being released but they just didn’t listen to what we had to say.

“For what he’s done he should never have been allowed out. It’s a matter of common sense but that’s not very common nowadays.

“He shouldn’t have been released at all for something so vicious, he was no use to society whatsoever.

“He was so manipulative and we knew he’d be more violent. If he’d been kept in Cherylee would still be alive. It makes you lose faith.”

Janine had been staying with her parents when she was waylaid by O’Hara in an entry between Great Meadow and Trent Road.

She was stabbed a dozen times and O’Hara only ceased the attack when the blade of the large knife snapped off in her body.

Neighbours heard agonising screams and Janine was found in a pool of blood in the 5ft-wide alley.

Mrs Waterworth said she was shocked by the leniency of the sentence and called for harsher punishments for violent crimes.

She said: “I think it should be a life for a life, the sentence was too lenient. In America life sentences are much longer and stricter.

“At the time we wanted him dead but now we want him to suffer. He’s a coward.

“When he came out he should have been nowhere near the area. He knew where I lived and Ian works away a lot.”
To read the full story go to the E-Chron digital edition via the website or buy the Chronicle.


The man is clearly a danger and consequently should have no place in civilised society.

The UK needs to adopt the United States legal system, this guy is obviously a sociopath or even worse a psychopath, one day the UK will adopt the system the USA has, it has to otherwise things like this will be a common occurrence & the general public will suffer as a result.

I'd like to see the parole board taken to task over releasing this monster but of course that won't happen because in their "expert" opinion he would not pose a threat.

Could you clarify what you mean by the "United States legal System"?

50 years since the last hanging , time to bring it back I think .I have never heard of an executed killer re-offending have you ?

I cannot even begin to imagine how Janine's family and friends (and Cherylee's) feel after a such a vile act has been committed again due to the leniency and inconsistency UK law.
The abolition of the death penalty in the UK may have been a good call for those who were dealt with and were later found to be innocent, but for those who are clearly guilty with concrete DNA evidence for proof, the law needs to be revised.


Have Your Say

Post New Comment


To post a comment you must first Log in.  Don't have an account? Register Now!