• Search

Negligence appeal dismissed

Date published: 03 September 2014

A woman who was violently assaulted by her father when she was a child has failed for a second time to convince a judge Oldham social workers were negligent.

The 26 year old claimed a seven-month delay in placing her in foster care in 1994, when she was six, blighted her life and resulted in her own young daughter being taken into care.

She claimed the warning signs of child abuse were present and that social workers failed to act quickly enough to save her from psychological scars.

The woman, known only as Kirsty X, gave birth to a baby girl when she was 20, but she was judged unfit and the child placed for adoption.

Kirsty X sued Oldham Council, claiming social workers had negligently delayed removing her from her parents’ care and that she hadn’t been appropriate care to overcome horrific childhood experiences.

Last year her claim was dismissed by a judge, and yesterday at the Appeal Court in London she was denied permission to appeal against the judgment.

Lord Justice Patten said however strongly Kirsty X disagreed with the initial judge’s conclusions, he had made no error of law and had dealt with the evidence in an “entirely conventional manner”.


Every one needs to be aware that the people they are forced to pay for, to make decisions on their behalf are pretty much unaccountable.
We've seen that in the case of Baby P and more recently in Rotherham. It doesn't matter if the decision is right or wrong, the fact that it needs a judge to make the final decision should be ringing alarm bells so loud it makes ear bleed!
Kirsty X was lucky she had access to law, most of never will have.
There's something very rotten in the Public sector

From what I've read it's clear that this woman has been severely let down by a system that ostensibly is there to help you.

Sorry Flake, she may or may not have been let down by the council. The fact is that the evidence to support that has been heard by two courts, neither have which have been convinced.


Have Your Say

Post New Comment


To post a comment you must first Log in.  Don't have an account? Register Now!