Plans to build a new Eton-backed sixth form college in Oldham are moving, ahead despite being dealt a major blow.

The Oldham Eton Star project has been pitched by Star Academies, one of the UK’s highest performing academy trusts, in partnership with privately-run Eton College. Eton is promising to provide investment and education expertise as part of the deal which would see a new school built in Oldham town centre.

Following Oldham market’s move into the Spindles shopping centre, the new school would be built on the site of the former Tommyfield Market. The location was chosen by the Department for Education due to good transport links to places across the region.

An agreement was reached over the town centre site with owners Oldham council in March 2026. Further public engagement will be carried out in 2027 as plans move forward next year.

A briefing sent to councillors highlighted how the school for up to 480 pupils would be state-funded, free-to-attend, and cater for pupils across Greater Manchester. Those behind the project say it would complement existing schools and prioritise people from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Oldham as an area performs poorly in education with only 29% of pupils who get high grade GCSEs going on to achieve top grades at college. In 2025, only 7.9% of Oldham’s pupils got into top universities compared to 12.1% across England.

Oldham council has now voted to back away from supporting the scheme. A motion put forward by the Liberal Democrats called for the scheme to be stopped claiming the idea ‘lacks both cross-party and public support’.

Councillor Mark Kenyon said he supported ambition for Oldham’s children but added: “It’s a bad deal because there’s such an imbalance. Oldham is giving up so much for so little whilst Eton gains so much with such little investment.”

Conservative Coun Max Woodvine said he supported the idea in principle but ‘at the moment this does not seem a very good deal for Oldham nor our parents or young people’. Reform’s leader Coun Paul Taylor said he supported the school idea but just not on Tommyfield.

Reform also attempted to withdraw its motion on the same subject claiming council legal advice had seen ‘the tragic death’ of their proposal. Coun Taylor said the Tommyfield site was ‘worth millions’ and claimed the party’s attempts to raise concerns about the location were being railroaded.

A majority of councillors did not support that and the motion calling for further scrutiny was later passed with Labour support. Oldham’s largest party said the school would open doors to top universities like Oxford and Cambridge but scrutiny would be a good thing.

Coun Elaine Taylor said the council needed to create more opportunities, adding: “Shouldn’t our focus be on helping the next generation achieve things that previous generations were too often denied? Oldham’s young people deserve better than political point scoring.”

Tom Arbuthnott, engagement lead for Eton Star Partnership, said: “Eton Star Oldham will bring a new, highly academic and supportive sixth-form offer to Oldham, widening choice and creating new opportunities for young people across the area. Its admissions arrangements are being designed to ensure that talented young people from disadvantaged backgrounds have a genuine opportunity to benefit.

“The college will complement existing post-16 provision, working with schools, communities and local partners to widen opportunity, raise aspiration and help more young people fulfil their potential. It also represents a significant investment in Oldham, contributing to the wider regeneration and renewed ambition for the town centre.

“Our ongoing engagement with local schools, education leaders, businesses and community organisations has been extremely positive, with widespread recognition of the opportunities the college will bring. We recognise the importance of listening to different views and will continue to engage openly and constructively as plans progress.”

A motion outlining the council’s opposition to new planning rules brought in by the government also passed despite those changes being adopted by the council in September. Councillors also voted to look at providing free bulky waste collections and help those on the lowest incomes.