An investigation has revealed a Greater Manchester council ’embarrassingly’ forgot to show what £1m of taxpayer cash was spent on by council staff.
Some councils across the country use government procurement cards, sometimes referred to as p-cards, for low-value and ad-hoc purchases. They have been described as ‘essentially a company credit card’ used by eligible council staff.
They can be used to make emergency payments, reduce paperwork, and speed up purchases from suppliers. However under local government transparency rules introduced in 2015, councils across the country who use them are required to publish what payments have been made to reassure people taxpayer cash is being used wisely.
Oldham council have now admitted they have not been revealing how these cards were being used and what taxpayer money has been spent on for eleven years. This is after no public records for payments were found by the LDRS.
The council is now working on publishing seven years’ worth of payment records, which is understood to be the length of time this data is required to be kept. Over this period, over £1m was spent by council and school staff.
It is understood no staff members had a personal card for expenses and the £1m figure includes spending by maintained schools. Some payments such as those over £500 may also have been published elsewhere and a town hall source said there was still internal oversight by staff managing budgets.
However the latest blunder has led to calls on the local authority to make sure the situation does not happen again.
When challenged over the matter, an Oldham council spokesperson said the council was looking to publish the information within a week, adding: “Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We have checked our published records and it’s clear procurement card spending is not currently available as a separate report on our website as it should be.”
Oldham council is not the first Greater Manchester council to end up in hot water over transparency on the use of these cards either. Salford council was criticised after it was discovered purchase cards were being used to cover expenses for some councillors.
Use of p-cards are restricted to key staff and are intended to be used when there is a clear need to. They are not meant to be used as credit cards and some concerns have previously been raised by the National Audit Office about their use in government departments.
The issue is now being called in for further scrutiny. Chair of the council’s governance scrutiny board and Conservative councillor Max Woodvine said: “This is a concerning oversight. While the full facts and figures are not yet confirmed, I understand most of the spend has been to support those individuals in need and in emergency situations.”
He added: “I have called this in to ensure full transparency. This will allow councillors to deep dive into the spending over the last 11 years and allow the truth and facts to be revealed to the taxpaying public of Oldham.”
On the streets of Oldham, the situation has done little to reassure people, with many questioning why the council had not been publishing the records. One person said the situation was embarrassing.
One man, Joseph, giving only his first name, said: “As an organisation the council is a business and the business is being paid by the public so the public have a right to know where the money is going. Is it being spent sensibly or is it being squandered?
“It’s their responsibility to tell the public. If you paid me to do a job in your house, you are allowed to ask me what I am buying and likewise with the council.”
The situation has been slammed by councillors too. Labour leader Arooj Shah said: “It’s absolutely not acceptable and should have been a core part of reporting. Public services should be open and transparent and my understanding from officers having raised this with them is that it was a genuine oversight.
“They have given me the assurance that they aim to rectify this as soon as possible and provide appropriate reporting as the guidelines expect them to do so.”
Liberal Democrat leader councillor Sam Al-Hamdani said: “This was introduced for a reason – to give the public reassurance. I keep banging the drum about oversight, scrutiny and transparency.
“They aren’t sexy politics, but they are about getting the basics right and building trust. Politicians need to care about getting the boring essentials right, not just grabbing headlines, and this is a perfect example.
“I’ll happily be boring if it means we’re doing more things right and people can see that.”











